The Mysterious Legend of “Cry Baby Lane,” Part II

Yesterday I wrote about the made-for-cable movie Cry Baby Lane. Aired only once by Nickelodeon in late October of 2000, it received enough calls from parents complaining about its content that the movie was shelved indefinitely. It was considered to be a lost film. Now 11 years later, through the power of the Internet, the movie has resurfaced. For science, I watched the movie in an attempt to discern why it might have been banned in the first place.

After yesterday’s post, some readers have mentioned that the tone of this movie does not seem any darker than the 1990s Nickelodeon show Are You Afraid of the Dark. They are probably right; however, I don’t think that creepiness was a major factor of why parents complained. I contend that it was the subversive elements of the story itself that disturbed parents.

From a parental authority perspective, there are many examples here that might give parents pause. This was not a golden example of a family unit. The mother was depicted as overprotective. The father even said to her, in front of the children, “You’re hovering.” A later scene when she yelled at the caretaker almost made her look hysterical. The father seemed aloof and uncaring. When the mother realizes that the boys are missing from the house at night, she shouts at the father, “They’re gone!” He simply looks up from the TV and says, “And …?” The older brother is often demeaning to his younger brother. They fight and wrestle, and not in that cute Nickelodeon play-fighting way. A rogue band of young girls goes on a destructive tear about town causing vandalism and general mayhem. Alarmingly, while bike riding, the boys play chicken with an oncoming train.

For most parents, the clincher had to be the scene when the father tried to explain to the mother that it should be okay for young boys to sneak out of the house at night:

“Look, Anne, you only had sisters. Boys are different, they need to explore. I think it’s healthy. I mean, if there was some boogeyman out there … but what’s gonna happen, they get muddy? Yeah, I could drive all night long, never find them, maybe fall asleep behind the wheel. But what kind of message would that send? What are we really saying here?”

What boys hear: Sneaking out of the house is okay! Do it! You won’t get in trouble!
What moms do: “Hello, Nickelodeon, I’d like to talk to you about the movie you’re showing right now …”

Let me make it clear, I do not believe there was a “message” to this movie. I think the director simply wanted to make something creepy that would be fun for kids on Halloween. And for that it succeeded. Unfortunately, it did not meet the expectations of many parents. It simply didn’t fit into the glossy sheen of the Nickelodeon brand. Parents all hopped up on family values during a major election year powered up the Great Babysitter on a Saturday night, and heard with dismay as one of the characters told their children that it’s all right to sneak out of the house at night. And I bet calling the mom “hovering” didn’t help matters much, either.

Thus unfortunately, we come to a disappointing end to our little Internet mystery.

  • What we wanted: A horrible depraved movie that blew us away, where a creepy director tried to slip one through the system, really stick it to the man, with plot twists and imagery that should never have been shown on a kids network. Thus prompting said network to pretend this travesty of a film never existed. Possibly, the director even pulled a Tyler Durden and slipped in subliminal images of gruesome degeneracy, the kind you would have to watch the entire movie frame by frame to uncover. No one would ever be the same after experiencing the grueling horror that was Cry Baby Lane.
  • What we got: The biggest controversy turned out to be arguing on Reddit over who the guy was sitting next to Melissa Joan Hart during the introduction. Some believe that it was a young Matt Damon. I think it was Brian Austin Green from 90210. But who knows? The truth is, right now nobody knows. And we may never really know the truth. Maybe some mysteries … should never be uncovered …

Cue dramatic music: [duh-duh-duuuuuuuuuuuh]


One thought on “The Mysterious Legend of “Cry Baby Lane,” Part II

Add yours

  1. Wow. I’m glad I never knew this existed. I relate to it not fitting into the “glossy sheen”. I let Maycee watch only a handful of shows on Nickelodeon, and we love watching Disney channel. Recently Disney has put on a show called, “My Babysitter’s a Vampire”. I can’t even believe they think this program goes along the lines of their “sheen”, either. I can’t stand it, wish they’d take it off the air and leave the air waves to better programs they already have such as “Good Luck, Charlie”. You have to be so careful with TV and not assume that because it’s a channel “for kids” what’s being played is the same. Interesting post, Jeff!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: